Fathers and Their Sons Who Commit Crimes

Defending Jacob by William Landay

A murder mystery that unfolds as a court room drama, Defending Jacob is a story told by the distraught father of the accused as he gives testimony. It's an odd position for Andy Barber who has, himself, been an assistant district attorney for more than 20 years. When a classmate of his son, Jacob, is murdered, he is surprised to find that Jacob is the prime suspect.

Through grueling testimony, Barber reveals both the history of the case and in flashbacks, the twisted family history, and his own efforts to focus suspicion in a different direction.

The case destroys Barber's career, ruins his happy marriage, and reveals his deepest secrets.

Landay carefully and skillfully reveals Jacob, the case against him, Barber's determination to clear his son, the complete annihilation of everything in Barber's life, and the secrets at the core of everything. The conclusion is unexpected, shocking, and utterly satisfying.

The Dinner by Herman Koch

This story begins with a dinner in an upscale restaurant in Amsterdam. The diners are two brothers and their wives. The younger brother and his wife arrive first and are seated. The older brother, a powerful politician, and his wife arrive with a flurry and the first hint that all is not as it appears.

As the dinner progresses, the friendly and courteous pretensions are chipped away and it is revealed that the diners must make a critical decision regarding their teen-aged sons.

The two cousins are involved in a horrifying incident that has resulted in police investigation. The two couples are determined to protect their children, but in serious conflict about how to do that.

The story is told through the musings and memories of the younger brother who has secrets of his own and shocking discoveries to make about his marriage and even the son he is trying to protect.

Both of these books focus on the two fathers and their desperate efforts to protect their sons. Both are well-written and suspenseful. Both are chilling because they leave you wondering, "What would I do if it were my child?"